The Glorious Revolution of 1688 was a turning point in British history, changing the balance of power between the monarch and Parliament and ending the Stuart Dynasty. In Scotland, especially among the Highland clans, it sparked a series of uprisings known as the Jacobite rebellions, which supported the reinstatement of the House of Stuart. This era is crucial for understanding Scottish history, loyalty, and identity. At the outset, the Jacobite risings from 1689 to 1746 were not just about Scottish nationalism or Catholicism. They were deeply rooted in the clan-based society of the Scottish Highlands. Knowing which clans supported or opposed the Jacobites, and their reasons, is key to understanding this chapter of history. The rebellion, in a peculiar way, came to embody its finality by the Scottish Enlightenment.
The term Jacobite comes from Jacobus, the Latin word for James. It referred to people who supported King James VII of Scotland and II of England, as well as his descendants. A full list is provided below.
King James I
King James became king of England and Scotland after his brother, King Charles II, died on 6 February 1685. He was a Roman Catholic and lost his throne when William of Orange arrived in England on 13 February 1689. James abdicated, and his infant son, James Francis Edward, who would have been next in line, was later called a pretender. James had upset Parliament and his people by trying to promote Catholicism and increase royal power. He used his "dispensing power" to get around the
Test Acts and put Catholics in top military, academic, and government jobs. Through the
Declaration of Indulgence, he tried to allow freedom of worship, but Parliament saw this as an illegal way to change laws without their approval. Parliament then declared James unfit to rule.
Parliament rebelled and asked William of Orange to come to England and take the crown. William was the king’s cousin and was married to the king’s Protestant daughter, who was next in line. After landing on the shores of England and after a short conflict, King James fled to France, which Parliament saw as an abdication. William, a Dutch Protestant, became William III of England and William II of Scotland, ruling with his wife Mary, James’s Protestant daughter.
William III of England and Mary II Joint Monarchs
The transfer of power in England was surprisingly peaceful, which is why it became known as the "Glorious Revolution" due to the lack of bloodshed, at least in England. This shift changed the balance of power, leading to the enactment of the
Bill of Rights and later the
Act of Settlement. Both brought constitutional changes that clearly limited the monarch's powers. As a result, Parliament became stronger than the monarch, setting the stage for the United Kingdom’s constitutional monarchy.
In Scotland, people saw the change in power differently. Many Scots disagreed with calling it an ‘abdication’ because they felt the king was forced off the throne instead of giving it up willingly.
This disagreement was central to the Scottish rebellion and the Jacobite Risings. The Scottish
Claim of Rights was created in response to the English
Bill of Rights; the latter limited the monarchy and made Parliament supreme. The Scottish version addressed Scotland’s unique legal, religious, and political situation, especially how kings could be removed. According to the Scottish Claim of Rights, the throne was illegally vacant because James did not abdicate but lost the crown as punishment for his actions- a forfeiture. This matched Presbyterian beliefs that power comes from the people and God, not just royal blood, limiting how power could be transferred. For the Scots, William and Mary were illegal usurpers occupying a stolen throne. England's straightforward view was that, since the throne was vacant through abdication, William and Mary's acquisition of the throne was perfectly legal.
Although many welcomed the change, others in Scotland saw James’s removal as an unlawful interruption of the line of succession and continued to recognise the Stuarts as Britain’s legitimate royal family. Many supporters believed in the hereditary right of kings and saw James's deposition as an unacceptable violation of legitimate royal authority. Moreover, the removal of James meant Catholics lost any hope of greater religious freedom, while many Protestants opposed Parliament's growing power. The process created conflicts in Scotland between Presbyterians and Episcopalians, and between upholders of the revolution's principles and outright Jacobite supporters across the Islands.
Recognition of the new royals hung heavily on the question of the divine right of Kings, a strict belief held by the Jacobites. William III and Mary II's sovereignty lacked that tradition. Tellingly, Parliament invited them to the throne, and they did not inherit the crown by divine right- hereditary right under God. The English Parliament marked a further break with tradition by requiring the new monarchs to accept the
Bill of Rights, which limited their power and established Parliamentary Sovereignty—a fundamental shift in Royal Authority. John Locke, the era's leading philosopher, put forward this argument in his
Two Treatises of Government, a blueprint that justified stripping monarchs of divine right and marked the birth of Great Britain’s constitutional monarchy.
At the risk of sidestepping a little, an aspect of Divine Right and the idea of anointing that still goes on today is worth briefly unpacking. The coronation ceremony, specifically the sacred act of anointing, still takes place today because it allows the monarch to retain the magical illusion of divine authority while remaining entirely subject to parliamentary law. When Prince Charles III was anointed, the ceremony mirrored medieval ritual. The meaning of that act has been completely inverted since James II. The British institution split into two distinct parts: the dignified (Monarchy) and the efficient (Parliament).
To get back to our story, revisionist historians believe professed loyalties were rarely consistent, with followers on either side shifting back and forth. Rather, political uncertainty and the difficulty of communicating at a distance, especially between Jacobites in Britain and the exiled Stuart court on the Continent, created opportunities for living a double life and behaviours of any sort. Double-crossing,
spying, double agents for both sides, and agile switches of allegiance. Among others was the Earl of Mar, a slippery figure who switched from supporting the Hanoverian succession to masterminding the Jacobite rising of 1715 (more of him below).
John Locke 1632 - 1704
For further interest,
John Locke’s philosophy underlined much of the architecture of the American Constitution.
The throne issue sparked a 60-year series of military campaigns. The first Jacobite rebellion began in Scotland in 1689, led by John Graham of Claverhouse, Viscount Dundee, who rallied supporters to fight for James’s restoration at the Battle of Killiecrankie in 1689. ‘Bonnie Dundee’ claimed victory in a vicious, gory fight against the much larger Redcoat (Government) army. In the process, Dundee lost his life, and following other bloody scenes at Dunkeld and Glen Coe, clans across Scotland started declaring allegiance to one side or the other. The fighting had only just begun. Concurrently, James II, returning from exile, landed in Ireland and engaged William III at the Battle of the Boyne in 1690.
At this stage, it is important, though difficult, to gain a clearer understanding; it's important to map out who is fighting whom since, as I said earlier, allegiances were at times thinly veiled and easily broken. However, sifting through the muddied complications, conflicting interests, paradoxical ideologies, and clan loyalties, understanding the Jacobite makeup is not straightforward. Who wanted what among the different branches of Clans: the MacDonalds, the Campbells, the Camerons, with different motivations between Highlanders and Lowlanders and commitments. Catholics fought alongside anti-Catholic Protestants in support of a Catholic King. Importantly, some supported the idea of God before the King, while others believed an anointed King is God’s appointment as divine right. Throughout this essay, I try to examine these complexities and the paradoxical nature of this period of Scottish History. Throughout all these different causes, I’ve come to understand that the Scots were slaughtering each other on their own soil mainly through sheer religious fanaticism.
Scotland was an independent kingdom that shared the same monarch but could choose its own succession, which added further complications. All the while, the essence was that the Jacobites were fighting a war of national Liberation. But within that same cause, soldiers fought for their own reasons.
Following the union of England and Scotland in 1707, skirmishes followed. In 1715 (the Fifteen), the Scots made their first major attempt to restore James II’s son, James Francis, the ‘Old Pretender ’, at the Battle of Sheriffmuir, near Dunblane, Scotland. The Union of England and Scotland was deeply unpopular in Scotland. Many saw it as an English takeover that ended Scottish independence, taxed their goods, and moved the centre of power to London. The spark of the anti-Union rebellion came when the German King George I took the British throne in 1714 following Queen Anne's death. He abruptly dismissed the Earl of Mar, then Secretary of State for Scotland, on suspicion of Stuart sympathies. Stung by this public rejection and seeing his political career ruined, Mar turned to the exiled Stuarts out of spite and a desire to regain power. Frustrated, he changed allegiance, raised the Jacobite standard and assembled 10,000 men made up of Highlanders and Lowlanders. They quickly seized control of Inverness, Aberdeen and Perth. He, however, failed to press his advantage and the confrontation eventually failed badly for the Scots. Then in 1719 (the nineteen), a rising heavily backed by Spanish allies ended with another defeat at the Battle of Glenshiel, southwest of Inverness.

Bonnie Prince Charlie (Charles Edward Stuart) 1720 - 1788
Died in France, having escaped the Massacre of Culloden.
The rebellion's climax came in the Forty-Five (1745), led by Charles Edward Stuart (Bonnie Prince Charlie) or the ‘Young Pretender’, a favourite with Scottish ladies for his good looks. The Jacobites, mainly made up of the Highlanders, captured Edinburgh and marched deep into England, gambling on high stakes to dethrone the English Hanoverian monarch. After securing Carlisle, he marched northwest into England, reaching Manchester, where, strangely enough, he was received with jubilation and hundreds of men enlisted in his army. Eventually he reached as far as Derby, not too far from Birmingham, but then retreated. The retreat stemmed from several factors. Lack of Support from France, hindered by storms while attempting to cross the Channel, and a lack of the anticipated protestant support south of Manchester.

The Battle of Culloden, where Scottish troops of Bonnie Prince Charlie met the English army led by the Duke of Cumberland, ended the Jacobite phase and stands as the last pitched battle ever fought on British soil. Cumberland's forces were highly trained and professional, including English regiments, a significant contingent of Lowland Scots, and pro-government Highland clans like the Campbells. Within one hour of heavy shelling, the Scots were routed, suffering very heavy casualties. The aftermath was ugly; Cumberland ordered his troops to show no quarter, leading to the execution of wounded Jacobites and prisoners. Government forces swept through the surrounding Highlands, killing suspected rebels and burning homes, earning Cumberland the permanent nickname "Butcher Cumberland". Many of the captured Highlanders were hustled together and put on a ship to the American colonies as indentured enslaved people, but en route were captured by Turkish pirates. The destructive campaign, however, aimed to erase the Gaelic way of life and to destroy Scottish identity, leading directly to bans on tartan, bagpipes, and the Highlanders' traditional carrying of daggers, broadswords, dirks and shields considered as instruments of war.
At this stage, it is worth stressing, and further clarifying earlier points, that Jacobitism was not a monolith but a paradox of conflicting beliefs, ideas, and causes. While the Stuart Princes themselves fought for absolutism, Catholic restoration, and divine right, the men doing the actual fighting often wanted something completely different. Scottish Highlanders and Nationalists wanted the repeal of the
Union Act of 1707 and a return to the Gaelic Clan system. Further complicating matters, Scottish Episcopalians and Catholics wanted religious freedom, while others wanted the Episcopalian Hanoverian kings removed.
It also helps to acknowledge that not all Highlanders were Catholic. By the time the transformation reached Scotland, the Lowland population was concentrated and fairly literate, so changing faith was easier than in the Highlands, where people were more dispersed, less literate, and received the new orders verbally. This meant faith was more diverse and fragmented in the Highlands than in the Lowlands, where Presbyterianism dominated.
Bonnie Prince Charlie promised to dissolve the union and restore Scotland’s Parliament. Protestant nationalists tolerated Charles’s Catholicism because he was the only figurehead powerful enough to break the treaty with England. So they believed, as the English before had believed his Catholic grandfather, James I, they overlooked their deeper religious resentments, foolishly believing they could use a Catholic Stuart as a tool. Hence, a blinded, paradoxical alliance of Protestant Presbyterians locked in with Catholic Stuarts for salvation and to dismantle English Protestant Episcopalianism. As I pointed out earlier, many Highlanders were Protestants who additionally feared that English standing armies would end the feudal Highland Clan system.
What is striking in this story is that the divine right of Kings was no longer the anchor of the English crown and its hereditary mandate; the Glorious Revolution put parliamentary sovereignty in its place. Though the Jacobite movement was defeated, in reality, its ideology and philosophy of divine absolutism remained. The British struck a political compromise by ensuring that while the Jacobites lost the war, their ideology survived. The sacred pageantry was not done away with, but incorporated, as we see today in the anointing of Charles III at his coronation. The Jacobites, although they lost the war, did indeed win in having a King who was sacred, mystical, and ordained by God.

The tragedy of the eighteenth century is that Scotland’s desperate struggle to figure out how to maintain its identity in a changing world resulted in Scots massacring each other on their own soil. Though the Culloden massacre tried to force change in Scottish identity, it was not to be. Eventually, the Scottish Enlightenment emerged out of this trauma as a peaceful way to preserve Scottish genius without warfare. The tartan and the sporran returned as an important feature of Scottish identity.
Scotland underwent one of the most astonishing intellectual transformations in human history. In the mid-to-late 18th century, Edinburgh and Glasgow became Europe's intellectual capitals. The Scots conquered the world with ideas, reinventing their national identity through sheer intellectual genius. Thinkers like David Hume (Philosophy) and Adam Smith (Economics, author of The Wealth of Nations, which later became the blueprint for capitalism), along with Scottish minds in medicine, geology, and engineering (James Watt's steam engine, which powered the Industrial Revolution), revolutionised thought and industry. With the help of such thinkers, Scotland consciously moved away from religious fanaticism. They championed reason, science, and human progress, embracing a new, enlightened Scottish identity.
The Scottish Enlightenment
Footnote: Points of interest.
The descendants of James I who carried on the Jacobite cause—claiming the thrones of England, Scotland, and Ireland after the Glorious Revolution of 1688—belong to the Stuart line of Jacobite pretenders:
- James II and VII (Grandson of James I): The deposed king who initiated the cause after being ousted in 1688.
- James Francis Edward Stuart (Great-grandson of James I): Known as the "Old Pretender" or James III and VIII, he led the cause from 1701 to 1766 and backed major uprisings like the 1715 rebellion.
- Charles Edward Stuart (Great-great-grandson of James I): Known as "Bonnie Prince Charlie" or the "Young Pretender", he famously led the 1745 Jacobite rising.
- Henry Benedict Stuart (Great-great-grandson of James I): The younger brother of Bonnie Prince Charlie and a Cardinal in the Catholic Church, he was the last direct Stuart descendant to publicly claim the throne (as Henry IX) until he died in 1807.
===================
The descendants of James I who came to the throne of England (and later Great Britain and the United Kingdom) in chronological order include:
- Charles I (son of James I, reigned 1625–1649)
- Charles II (Protestant, son of Charles I, grandson of James I, reigned 1660–1685)
- James II (Catholic, son of Charles I, grandson of James I, reigned 1685–1688)
- Mary II (Protestant, daughter of James II, great-granddaughter of James I, reigned jointly 1689–1694, with William III)
- Anne (Protestant, daughter of James II, great-granddaughter of James I, reigned 1702–1714)
- George I (great-grandson of James I through his mother, Sophia of Hanover, reigned 1714–1727)
(Note: William III ruled jointly with his wife Mary II, though William was a grandson of Charles I through his mother Mary, Princess Royal, rather than a direct descendant in the royal line of succession.)
No comments:
Post a Comment