Sunday, 19 July 2020

Mind the Gap



Mind The Gap

Battle-scarred Britain must look after its own to narrow the gap of inequality.

As the COVID-19 outbreak took hold, it quickly became a global pandemic in March 2020, and governments worldwide imposed various forms of 'lockdown'. Social media highlighted comparisons and contrasts between different experiences of quarantine and self-isolation. Much of this suggested the pandemic's uneven consequences. Beyond the destructive effects COVID-19 has inflicted worldwide, it has done more here in the UK.  The result has spotlighted the widening gap in quality of life between affluent areas and deprived ones, often sitting side by side. This adjacency further magnifies the inequality, particularly in income and wealth.  Despite the apparent fact that the virus does not discriminate between rich and poor, a disproportionate effect continues to exist: the poor, with the least capacity to protect themselves and those privileged in well-protected areas are more vulnerable to the devastating impact of this killer virus. I will analyse the reasons for these disparities, their long-term effects, and what the government can do to close the widening gap, level up the economy, and create opportunities for a fairer Britain.  

Even the altruistic spirit generated during the peak of Covid-19 infections, seeing key workers carrying on with their duties in defiance of the dangers, is exposing them. Also, the solidarity exhibited: an appreciative public, daily clapping across the country, grateful for the effort these people are putting in to save lives.  A touching moment, and we may yet see more of the same going forward.  Similar bonding occurred immediately post-WWII, and government responses were no less affirmative. Significant steps were taken to restructure social institutions and moderate Capitalism to care for as many people as possible.

The government measures to ease income-loss pain for individuals and companies alike are similar in this regard.  Those who were compensated by being furloughed, and companies that received grants covering up to 80% of salaries, along with other protective measures, were taken to insulate individuals against rent, eviction, rates, and so forth.  Western governments alike endeavoured to show that the liberal democratic system works and democracy can indeed fit in with Capitalism.

Unfortunately, many, especially young and angry people, disagree. The uncertainty and the security the government tries to establish have lost their popularity and trust.  It is a bitter cry caused long before the advent of Coronavirus, but dissatisfaction and rage have been brewing for some time.  Today's youth carry heavy baggage; their disadvantages are numerous: opportunities, housing, education, to name a few.  Those who fail to make the grade and gain a foothold in any of them find it a hard struggle to break the chain of this ongoing burden.  Especially those who are uneducated and miss out on life's opportunities because they remain unaware of how to seize seemingly opaque opportunities. Not realising that any one of them may likely be an open door.

Many factors can perpetuate this never-ending struggle to make ends meet.  Well-paid manufacturing jobs that once paid just about enough to put bread on the table have been replaced by low-paying service jobs.  The uneducated and the unskilled have no chance to escape; they end up in the life of crime, drugs and idleness or increasingly dependent on the state for a handout.  Those from broken homes suffer most.    Even young, university-educated people are savvy enough to grab life's opportunities, but find it hard to make ends meet when they have to tackle the high cost of housing, especially in London. 


A scene in Tower Hamlet, one of the most deprived areas of London.


On average, households in London spend 18% of their net income on meeting housing costs.  Job insecurity, coupled with most income going to rent, is a heavy load to carry.  Without occasional handouts from parents, even on special occasions, it feels like an unwarranted burden, and many do not have generous parents or parents rich enough to help.  For many, coming to terms with their lot is hard; realising they are on the poor side of a divided society can only fuel anger and frustration.  Even continued, near-full employment would have mitigated the effects of inequality or pulled in the divide. This situation fares even worse with Black people and some Asian people, mainly Bangladeshi, who face prejudice and discrimination at almost all levels, whether institutionalised or systemic, as they go through life.

After all, it was not long ago that the banks, partly responsible for the 2008 global financial crisis, got billions, while a pittance went to homeowners and victims of the same banks' predatory lending practices. The angry crowd feels the financial help was misplaced; instead, it should have gone directly to affected homeowners, which would not only have helped them but also helped the economy achieve a robust recovery from the 2008/2009 depression. To add to the pain, the system was implemented during severe austerity, further restricting their income.   On the other side of the scale are the investment bankers, on Wall Street and Main Street. Like the city of London's executives, they built a wall of lawyers to shield them from blame and ensure they are not held accountable for other people's misfortune. The banks went on to abuse the UK legal system to foreclose on mortgages and evict people. It is no exaggeration to say that one of the reasons the youth are angry at governments is for allowing such immoral Capitalism to corrupt democracy.  The rules are designed by those who stand to benefit from them.  They can exploit the poverty trap.  Also, many of those young people who are anti-authoritarian perceive the UK government as overseeing corporate welfare, allowing within the system enough critical features in terms of profits, taxes and social limitations to curtail welfare for the poor.  The rich and powerful mainly conceive the system and pressure the government.    At all levels, such detachments by two sides of the socio-economic divide, the outcome of which is increasing inequality and poverty, can lead to social unrest and segregation.  For the poor, choice is not an option. Neither is it an option for Black and Asian people to avoid the chequered effect.

London City Skyline a couple of miles away from Aldwych High Street.


It is natural for many Londoners, or those aware enough to recognise, to see private capital sit side by side with run-down public housing occupied by low-income residents.  The best example is the dividing line of the M40, which separates the two Kensingtons, where the horrible events of Grenfell Tower come to mind.  The blackened shell is visible from the immaculate Georgian terraces of Notting Hill and Holland Park. The mean household income across the borough of Kensington and Chelsea was £116,000 a year, the highest in London. Yet research found the district was the capital's most polarised borough, with more than half of benefit recipients living in the most deprived quarter of neighbourhoods. In this borough, as in Camden, Islington, Westminster, and elsewhere, wealth and deprivation rub shoulder to shoulder.  Especially since the lockdown and the spread of COVID, the spotlight has shone a brighter light on densely packed areas such as Brixton, Tower Hamlets, etc., to show that Wealth is very unequally distributed among Londoners. Those in the bottom half of London's wealth distribution hold just 6.8% of the capital's total wealth, compared with those in the top 10%, who hold 42.5%.


To explore ways in which quality of life is a priority for any government to tackle to make cities a "fairer" place to live and work. Central to that task is tackling inequality, particularly of income and wealth.  Poor and rich people are increasingly living separately, with an ever-widening gap in between, which can threaten the social dynamics of cities.  London, in particular, is experiencing segregation and clustering, primarily driven by affordability, especially when social mobility is not by choice, which is a growing problem.  The number of people in poverty is best measured by the number of families whose children need free school meals (FSM). 

Every child born is a new generation.  Living in poverty-concentrated neighbourhoods is passed down across generations. Neighbourhood poverty can be contagious, spreading over time through households' residential mobility. This is mainly caused by the misguided urban policy of demolishing houses in deprived areas only to replace them with housing for the middle class. A malicious attempt at desegregation that can only redistribute poverty to other areas. Such harmful forced social mobility, meant to reduce inequality, can only add to it.  Instead, we must reduce inequality by creating opportunities and investing in education. An inclusive growth strategy should focus on both people and housing.


Inequality in London is far greater than in the rest of England. When combined with housing costs are much higher than in other parts of England.  Given current housing costs, it is no surprise that poverty is more prevalent in London than in any other part of the UK. In fact, based on the relative low-income measure of poverty (after housing costs), 28% of Londoners (2.5 million people) are in poverty, compared with 22% in England overall. Inner London has poverty rates that are 10 percentage points higher than in many parts of the North of England.  Over half of Londoners living in single-parent families are living in poverty, four in ten children in London live in households in poverty, 25% of working-age adults in London are living in poverty.  Pensioners and the disabled make up the rest.



Housing is often the single biggest expense for any household and a major driver of poverty in London. It also plays a crucial role in well-being by fostering a secure sense of place. Many Londoners suffer from this shortfall of good-quality housing. At the extreme end of the scale are those living at the mercy of slumlords, living in a caravan or the 'Vanlifers'.  Their problem of homelessness also extends from rough sleeping to sofa surfing. On average, households in London spend 18% of their net income on meeting housing costs. This compares with 11% in the rest of England.  For those in poverty, they face housing costs that, on average, amount to 56% of their net income. Beyond affordability, Londoners also face real issues with the nature of housing in London, such as property condition, tenancy security, and overcrowding. While the fall in the proportion of households below the Decent Homes Standard has been slightly faster in London than in the rest of England, over half a million homes still fall short of what is considered decent. Another issue is overcrowding. Nearly one in four children (22%) in London live in overcrowded accommodation, twice the proportion in the rest of England (11%). The issue is most prevalent among those living in the social rented sector, where four in ten children (40%) live in overcrowded accommodation.

What this has meant is a definite shift in housing redistribution, with people moving out to outer suburbs or into poor areas, adding to the burden of overcrowding and further fueling the effects of Socio-economic segregation.  Studies show that rising inequality significantly increases disconnection and argue that high levels of isolation can undermine cities' social stability. The riots in Paris (2005), London (2011) and Stockholm (2013) cannot be seen separately from high concentrations of poverty in these cities, often in combination with high levels of ethnic segregation.

Low-income residents have fewer choices about where to live than high-income earners.  This demographic inequality began after the financial crisis in 2008, but has gained momentum since then.  London has a dire need for affordable housing, so the inflow and outflow of those serving the rich and affluent spend less time and money on travel.  This hard evidence puts pressure on the Greater London Authority to build more affordable housing, faster. But, as the Grenfell disaster showed, London's housing crisis is one of quality as well as quantity.  This is not socialism but social care.

A time bomb is waiting. Rising income and wealth inequality is a major concern because it also influences other life domains, such as education, health, life expectancy, and employment prospects. Inequality can undermine social stability and erode trust in governments and institutions. It could even put democratic processes at risk as lower-income groups become disengaged from politics. The Liberal viewpoint may have come back to haunt us, as shown by the anger we see around us.  It is difficult to see a peaceful demonstration without it being peppered with violence directed at the authorities.  The risk of peaceful protests going out of control is ever-present, where passion runs high, mainly from anger and frustration. This was clearly demonstrated by the recent near-riots in support of Black Lives Matter in London. The system that lets them express their anger is the very system that is failing them. 

Since 1991, partly due to globalisation and the rise in employment and self-employment, income inequality has continued to rise, but several factors have mitigated the effect of these changes on total income inequality. First, before COVID-19, the disparity between different employment statuses fell, mainly because unemployment fell, though most of the unemployed were in low-pay work. Second, since 1991, employment taxes have played a larger role in mitigating the rise in inequality in gross employment income than before 1991. Third, investment income has contributed less to total income inequality since 1991, mainly because it has become less important as an income source. Finally, a rise in the relative incomes of pensioners and households with children under five – both groups that benefited from reforms to welfare benefits and tax credits during the 1990s and (especially) the 2000s – has pulled down inequality. Overall, since 1991, these four factors have almost entirely offset the impact of inequality-increasing changes in the distribution of earnings and self-employment income.

Post-COVID-19, however, the outlook, at least in the short term, is bleak. Future movements in net earnings inequality are, therefore, likely to become central to the trend in income inequality.  Now it is the rich's turn, more than the government's, to restart the economy and encourage recovery, to help limit the further scarring effect COVID is leaving behind.  Time to help these vulnerable groups across London and the country break the link between poverty and deprivation. Above all, help narrow the gap by making borrowing more accessible and changing the social infrastructure, so they can enjoy the sunlight of opportunity and start to chart their own destinies.   In compensation, the rich have to swallow a bitter pill of higher taxes to redistribute their wealth, but this time to desegregate, narrowing the social distance.  Consider it payback for the protection and service of those key low-paid workers carrying on their duties of saving lives, aware of the invisible enemy and defiant in the face of the dangers it poses.  For those spirited nurses' altruistic actions, cleaners, and all those who kept the NHS, the backbone of healthcare, open all hours; for them, working from home was never an option. 

After all, for those at the top to keep enjoying the best health care, education, and the benefits of wealth, the one per cent's fate is bound up with how the other ninety-nine per cent live.  The Price of Inequality need not be so high; time to create a more dynamic economy and a fairer, more equal society. Social distancing may not always be the answer.  











No comments: